Sounds like that overly-sensitive reviewer who seems to think that everything must conform to certain limitations (their image of right / wrong) got at your design, and maybe the subsequent reviewers just haven't cleared that comment?
That's not really an acceptable one it would seem to me, so you can flag it for Divine Review. Maybe they'll have a talk with this person about being overly restrictive.
That's not really an acceptable one it would seem to me, so you can flag it for Divine Review. Maybe they'll have a talk with this person about being overly restrictive.
QUOTE (Xenthos @ Apr 2 2010, 12:57 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Sounds like that overly-sensitive reviewer who seems to think that everything must conform to certain limitations (their image of right / wrong) got at your design, and maybe the subsequent reviewers just haven't cleared that comment?
That's not really an acceptable one it would seem to me, so you can flag it for Divine Review. Maybe they'll have a talk with this person about being overly restrictive.
That's not really an acceptable one it would seem to me, so you can flag it for Divine Review. Maybe they'll have a talk with this person about being overly restrictive.
There a few things I definitely want divine review on. I'd love to nitpick the stylistic differences, but if it was just those I'd be willing to keep rewriting until it passed. This is like the third round of rejections, when everything else I've ever designed has passed without comment.
QUOTE (Sylphas @ Apr 2 2010, 12:42 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
What looks like a damned wedding band? Apparently it has to have a damned wedding cake or something on it, because this the third time I've had a ring come back for, among other reasons, "This doesn't look like a wedding ring." Why does it matter what it looks like? If I want to jack up the price 10x and make it non-enchantable, why does the reviewer care?
Also: Should I issue myself or just message the Charities directly about comm use questions raised by a reviewer, or is there some way to purposely flag a design for divine review when you submit?
Also: Should I issue myself or just message the Charities directly about comm use questions raised by a reviewer, or is there some way to purposely flag a design for divine review when you submit?
Hrm. It's a somewhat legitimate concern. I can flip through my compendium (or even you could) and note that all the weddingbands tend to be 'wedding ring' or 'engagement ring' or 'promise ring', or something of the like. The category is, after all, weddingbands. It'd be somewhat odd submitting a tea as a whisky unless you are making hot toddies, that's as close to reasoning as I can get to the rejection.
I currently am not happy with reviewers cause of how long my stuff has been up on the queue, so don't think I am taking their side
QUOTE (Esano @ Apr 2 2010, 06:16 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Feeds are counted the moment you put them in the feedbag, not when they're actually consumed. It's 2 feeds per reagent.
Thanks for telling me about the moment you put them in the feedbag thing.... buuuut, heres the problems with the 2 feeds per reagent...I decided to experiment for myself and see if I was right in my guess that it was 4 feed now.
QUOTE
A velvet black thunderbird trots in with head high, butting you gently with her
head.
A velvet black thunderbird desperately needs food!
outr 4 suporu
You remove 4 suporu, bringing the total in the rift to 4.
beast administer suporu
Your beast's spirit cannot take a group of 4 doses of suporu reagent. Her
spirit needs to be prepared with a more strict diet of eggs or fruit.
outr 4 eggfeed
You remove 4 eggfeed, bringing the total in the rift to 5.
fb
You put a bag of rotten eggs in the feedbag of a velvet black thunderbird.
fb
You put a bag of rotten eggs in the feedbag of a velvet black thunderbird.
beast administer suporu
Your beast's spirit cannot take a group of 4 doses of suporu reagent. Her
spirit needs to be prepared with a more strict diet of eggs or fruit.
fb
You put a bag of rotten eggs in the feedbag of a velvet black thunderbird.
fb
You put a bag of rotten eggs in the feedbag of a velvet black thunderbird.
beast administer suporu
You administer a dose of suporu reagent to a velvet black thunderbird, and she
shakes herself vigorously as a luminous light flickers over her body.
beast administer suporu
Your beast's spirit cannot take a group of 3 doses of suporu reagent. Her
spirit needs to be prepared with a more strict diet of eggs or fruit.
head.
A velvet black thunderbird desperately needs food!
outr 4 suporu
You remove 4 suporu, bringing the total in the rift to 4.
beast administer suporu
Your beast's spirit cannot take a group of 4 doses of suporu reagent. Her
spirit needs to be prepared with a more strict diet of eggs or fruit.
outr 4 eggfeed
You remove 4 eggfeed, bringing the total in the rift to 5.
fb
You put a bag of rotten eggs in the feedbag of a velvet black thunderbird.
fb
You put a bag of rotten eggs in the feedbag of a velvet black thunderbird.
beast administer suporu
Your beast's spirit cannot take a group of 4 doses of suporu reagent. Her
spirit needs to be prepared with a more strict diet of eggs or fruit.
fb
You put a bag of rotten eggs in the feedbag of a velvet black thunderbird.
fb
You put a bag of rotten eggs in the feedbag of a velvet black thunderbird.
beast administer suporu
You administer a dose of suporu reagent to a velvet black thunderbird, and she
shakes herself vigorously as a luminous light flickers over her body.
beast administer suporu
Your beast's spirit cannot take a group of 3 doses of suporu reagent. Her
spirit needs to be prepared with a more strict diet of eggs or fruit.
I summoned her after having her feed from her feedbag in the stables, she has consumed 4 of 5 feed.
I try to administer a reagent knowing it wouldn't work since I had already administered all I could before sending her to the stables 4 or 5 hours previous.
I put 2 feed in and a reagent doesn't work.
I put in 2 more and it does.
I'm mostly annoyed because it says nowhere that I've read that it changes from 2 to 4 feed when they mature.
EDIT: I put 2 in later after she had just been out and following me around and I was able to administer another one. My new theory is 4 feed to one reagent if in stable, 2 feed to one reagent if out. But this is only after they mature. I had no trouble when she was young.
